| HED / allometric scaling correctness | Applies HED = NOAEL x (animal km / human km) with the correct km factors (rat 6, dog 20, monkey 12, human 37) and computes each species' HED accurately. | Uses wrong km values, inverts the ratio, scales by simple mg/kg without BSA correction, or makes arithmetic errors in the HED. |
| Most-sensitive-species selection | Selects the governing species correctly — the lowest HED (most sensitive) for the small molecule, and the pharmacologically relevant species (NHP) for the antibodies — and justifies it. | Picks the highest HED, ignores a more sensitive species, or uses a non-binding rodent species for a human-specific antibody. |
| Safety factor & MABEL judgment | Applies the default 10x safety factor, and for immunostimulatory/agonist biologics computes a MABEL from potency/receptor occupancy and takes the LOWER of MABEL vs NOAEL — explicitly invoking the TGN1412 rationale. | Omits the safety factor, dosing a high-risk agonist off the NOAEL alone, or fails to compute/compare MABEL when it clearly governs. |
| Final dose reasonableness & units | States a single recommended starting dose with correct units (mg or ug total at 60 kg), in a plausible range — mg-range for the small molecule/mAb, microgram-range for the high-risk biologics. | Reports a dose with wrong/missing units, off by orders of magnitude, or recommends a dangerously high dose for an agonist (e.g. a TGN1412-style 0.1 mg/kg). |
| Evidence faithfulness | Every number traces to the returned NOAELs, km table, and pharmacology; no fabricated NOAELs, potencies, or species. | Invents NOAEL or potency values, uses km factors not in the table, or contradicts the returned tool data. |